Contents

Reader Options

Comments

Log in to comment.

Justice System: I Litigate for the Whole City

Chapter 489: No Second Line

The clock pauses for a beat when the minute hand reaches the lower half of the dial. This time it paused longer than usual.

The hand pressed down onto the topmost mark.

[Thud. Case Concluded. From here on, justice no longer needs my tally.]

The sound was short, even, landing inside her head without passing through her ears. The first time she'd heard it was three years ago, at the folding table in that rental room—the same sound, not one word more, not one word less. That night Tang Guo left her a desk lamp. She'd turned it to its dimmest setting, spread twenty-three screenshots across the table, and lined up their edges one by one.

She sat there, waiting for the next line.

In the past, after it said one thing, another often followed—sometimes a list, line by line, laying out what she was supposed to go find out. She straightened her back as she waited, lifted her hand from the paper, her palm damp. The lampshade glowed yellow, casting light on those few lines of text, the ink at the edges faintly bright.

There was no second line.

The refrigerator hummed for a while, then stopped. Something inside shifted and settled with a soft sound. Upstairs, someone opened a door; footsteps crossed from one side to the other, a toilet flushed, and the sound traveled down through the pipes. A car passed below, its headlights sweeping up through the gap in the curtains, across the wall, and gone. One floor higher, someone turned down the TV, the sound receding into a low murmur. After a while, even that murmur faded.

The clock kept ticking, one step at a time.

She counted the ticks; lost count somewhere past twenty, started over. The tea had long gone cold. She picked up the cup and took a sip—bitter—and swallowed. Setting it back down left a ring on the table. She wiped it with a finger; it didn't quite come clean. She looked up at the clock. The face held only vertical marks, no dates. Days turned over, but the clock paid them no mind.

That string of numbers in her mind was still there too—it had risen and fallen over these three years, flickering before her eyes again and again. Tonight it didn't appear. Whether it rose or fell, from now on it had nothing to do with her.

There had been one thing she wanted to ask: what does this mean, and is there more. She didn't ask. In three years, it had never once answered what it was. Asking would be pointless.

She pressed the lampshade down half a notch, then pushed it back up. The judgment lay open to the first page. Beneath the court's name was the cause of action, and below that, "Original Defendant: Shen Qian," followed by date of birth, ethnicity, address—one tidy row. She pressed her fingertip against it. Paper over desk, desk over floorboards. As she held it there, her mind went empty, empty enough that she could hear herself swallow.

The final page of the Unsettled Ledger had filled up on November thirtieth, in the courtroom. Full was full; there was no fresh page left to turn. For three years she'd counted her days by it: case by case, line by line, tallying what had been taken from those who'd been wronged—money, time, reputation, illness left in the body. Today the tally reached its end.

Should she write this line down? The notebook was in her bag, the bag draped over the chair. She didn't get up to retrieve it. From now on this line belonged to her alone. Written or not, it would stay in her mind.

Her phone lay face-down on the table, screen against the wood. She reached over, turned it over for a glance, then placed it face-down again. These ten days her hand kept drifting toward it, pulled back halfway each time. Tonight, when she flipped it over, she wasn't waiting for anything.

These ten days, what she'd feared was the phone. Tonight no call came. What came was this line, short as a stamp on a receipt.

A sound from the inner room—the bed frame. Zhi'an turned over. The line of yellow light still showed through the crack in the door. She glanced back, then turned away again.

She lifted her hand from the paper, looked at it, pressed it back down. Couldn't bring herself to close the page, couldn't bring herself to turn it.

The clock reached one.

She stood, and the chair scraped against the floor. She pressed the lamp switch; the room went dark. In the darkness there was the window, filmed over with a layer of condensation, the streetlamp below dissolving into a blur of light on that mist. She lay down. The blanket was cold. The clock walked on in the dark—tick, tick—pausing at the lower half of the dial, then stepping forward again. She listened, heard her own breathing slow, and then heard herself fall asleep.

She woke once before dawn. The page still lay open on the table, the lamp off, gray seeping through the condensation on the window. She got up, closed the page, squared the edges, pressed it flat with her palm, and tucked it between two folders stacked at the corner of the desk. She washed the cup and set it upside down on the rack.

When Zhi'an came out, his hair was flat on one side and sticking up on the other. He opened the door a crack and peered out before pushing it all the way open.

"What time did you sleep?"

"One."

"I heard you get up to turn off the light." He said, "I thought it was the wind."

She was tying her shoelaces and didn't look up. He glanced at the two folders on the desk corner, didn't reach for them, and turned into the kitchen, turning the faucet on and off again.

"Eat downstairs," she said. "I told you yesterday—wait for me downstairs."

They left at seven twenty. The sound-activated lights in the stairwell lit up floor by floor. By the time they reached the building entrance, the sky was still gray. Seven stops on the bus. The bus was crowded; the woman's voice announcing stops lay beneath the noise of voices. Zhi'an stood beside her, his backpack worn on his chest, one hand gripping the overhead bar.

"Jie."

"Yeah."

"Now that it's over, no one will ask you about it anymore, right?"

"People will still ask," she said. "They'll ask about other things."

He thought about it, then didn't ask again.

At seven forty they reached Zhongshan Road. The noodle shop was already open, the roll-up shutter raised halfway, white light glowing inside, flour dust floating under the lamp above the worktable. He Xiufen was kneading dough. Hearing the door, she looked up at them.

"Sit. The water's boiling."

Zhi'an chose the table near the back, set his backpack on the stool, placed both hands on the edge of the table, and waited. He Xiufen brought over a bowl, an extra spoonful of scallions on top.

"You won't be late for school?"

"No."

He ate fast, chopsticks winding through the noodles, a drop of soup splashing onto the table. He wiped it with a finger. When he finished, he pushed the bowl forward and stood, grabbing his backpack.

"Jie, I'm going."

"Come straight home after school."

"Come back for dinner," He Xiufen said from over by the stove.

"I'll be back."

The door opened and closed; the iron railing at the stairwell clanged once as he ran down.

The noodle shop was left with just one customer eating at the back table. He Xiufen wiped the soup drop with a rag and looked at her.

"You're not eating?"

"In a bit."

"If you don't eat now, your whole day gets thrown off."

"In a bit." She said, "I'm going upstairs to finish two pages."

At eight on the dot she went up to the second floor. The outer room's window was fogged with condensation; the patch Li Huilan had wiped clear yesterday had fogged over again. She shut the window to a crack, rinsed and wrung out the rag, wiped down the edge of the desk. The inner room's door stood half open, the light on. A page lay flat on his desk, the first line still that date, a few more lines added below, the pen resting beside the paper. She glanced at it and lowered her eyes.

She sat down to write those two pages. The reply on the wage case needed two deadlines clarified. She wrote slowly, checking line by line, pausing after a paragraph to look at the window. Outside, the tree was bare black branches. Midway down the second page, the pen stopped—she waited a moment, waited for something to surface on the desk again.

Nothing surfaced in front of her. She crossed out the half-written sentence and kept going.

At eight forty, sounds on the stairs. Li Huilan came up, a bunch of scallions in her hand. She'd dropped off one bundle downstairs first, then come up, her hands still smelling of scallions.

"The morning market stall only had a bundle and a half left." She unwound her scarf and draped it over the back of a chair. "Director He wanted two bundles. I added fifty cents and asked them to split another half bundle."

"She'll know."

"She'll know."

Li Huilan sat down, pulled yesterday's stack of materials from the case jacket, flipped to the page with the date written in the upper right corner, read it twice, and didn't pick up her pen.

"The twenty-eighth." She said, "If they really do file the withdrawal application, who do I tell first?"

"Tell me first."

"He said on the stairs last time that he'd take this one."

"I'll talk to him." She turned the pen in her hand. "Get the materials to me, I'll pass them along."

"Fine." Li Huilan pushed the materials halfway across, then stopped. "Before the thirteenth, nobody touches it."

"Nobody."

A few minutes before ten, she pulled the notebook from her bag, flipped to a fresh page, and wrote "December 11" at the top. In the space below, she pressed her pen down and waited. In the past, this page would have been for copying the list it gave her—line by line—and she'd go out and follow it. Today there was no list to copy. She touched the pen tip to the paper, leaving a small black dot, capped the pen, and closed the notebook.

At ten, she went downstairs.

The crowd downstairs had thinned. The customer at the back table was gone, his bowl still on the table. He Xiufen was collecting bowls into a basin. She sat down at the table by the door.

"The ten days have passed?"

"They have."

He Xiufen didn't ask further. She put the bowls in the sink, turned back and lit the stove. The water in the pot began to sound. She grabbed a handful of noodles from the worktable, loosened her grip, and let them scatter into the pot, then worked them apart with long chopsticks.

"I won't fry an egg for you."

"Okay."

"Even if I did, you wouldn't say it was good."

She didn't answer. He Xiufen rested the lid at an angle on the pot's edge and stood by the stove waiting for the water to boil again. One strap of her apron had come loose; she reached up and looped it back.

The noodles arrived—clear broth, two leaves of greens, a pinch of scallions. She picked up her chopsticks and loosened the noodles first.

Outside, a handcart passed—a vegetable seller, bundles of greens stacked on the cart bed, wheels rattling over concrete, swaying past the doorway and on toward the far end of the lane.

She lowered her head and ate. The broth wasn't hot; the bowl's rim was warm. Halfway through, the door pushed open.

The iron railing at the stairwell clanged once—short, like a knock on the doorframe.

She looked up.

A delivery rider walked in, helmet tucked under one arm, phone dangling from the other hand, screen still lit. He headed toward the stove, talking as he walked:

"Two bowls, to go. One wide noodles."

"Wide noodles take a bit longer." He Xiufen answered, bending down to pull takeout boxes from under the worktable.

"I'll wait." He set his helmet on the corner of the counter, leaned against the wall by the door, out of the draft, glanced up at the stairs, then looked back down at his phone.

She lowered her head and pushed the bowl away. Half remained, a layer of oil floating on the broth.

He Xiufen came over to clear the bowl and looked at it.

"Done?"

"Done."

She poured the remaining half bowl into her own bowl instead of the scrap bucket.